A panel of five dismisses Uthayakumar’s application to declare the act null and void.
PUTRAJAYA: The Federal Court today unanimously dismissed Hindraf activist P Uthayakumar’s application to declare the Sedition Act 1948 as null and void.
Chief Justice of Malaya Zulkefli Ahmad Makinudin, who led a panel of five judges, said there was “no merit” in the argument made by Uthayakumar’s lawyer, M Manoharan.
“The Sedition Act is a good law,” he said. “It is not ultra vires against Articles 4, 5, 8 and 10″ of the Federal Constitution.
The other judges in the panel were Suriyadi Halim Omar, Hasan Lah, Zaleha Zahari and Zainun Ali.
The application to declare the act unconstitutional was first filed in the High Court in 2010, after Uthayakumar was charged under the act over an open letter that he addressed to former British Prime Minister Gordon Brown in 2007.
In the letter, he described racial clashes in Kampung Medan as ethnic cleansing.
Last year, the Appeals Court also rejected the application on the grounds that there was no merit in the case.
Manoharan argued that the act should be declared null and void on four grounds – seditious tendency is insufficient, intentions are irrelevant, truth is irrelevant in sedition, and the act violates Articles 4, 5, 8 and 10 of the Federal Constitution.
Deputy public prosecutor Noorin Badawi, appearing for the government, said the Sedition Act maintained public order.
She also said Article 10 of the Federal Constitution did not provide for absolute freedom.
You might also like
Sedition Act violates freedom of speech, submits M.Manoharan @ HINDRAF de facto leader Uthaya case @ Court of Appeal. (Malaysiakini/Bernama)
UMNO apex Federal Court decides no freedom of speech for Hindraf to speak truth on state racism & discrimination targeting Indians in 1 Malay-sia.
Biased UMNO Court of Appeal & Putrajaya upholds malicious sedition prosecution against Uthayakumar on Hindraf letterhead. Even a stay not allowed.
Federal Court Malay-sia dismisses P. Uthayakumar’s 215 pages Sedition Review without even A.G Gani Patail replying to affidavit: UMNO govt political directions? Not end of road. Another Federal Court Review to be filed when Sedition Act repealed.
UMNO Federal Court dismiss Uthaya’s stay of proceedings in Gordon Brown Sedition charge trial @ Sessions Court: Conviction to bar standing in GE 13
Uthaya’s Sedition trial : Malay-sian Federal Court 5 man bench play acts by pretending to confer in open Court but actually delivers UMNO Judgment in rejecting Review application that Sedition Act not ultra vires Constitution.
Media Event 9/8/2012 : Filing of Federal Court, Putrajaya Review Application for Sedition Charge against P. Uthayakumar to be struck off in the spirit of announcement of repeal of Sedition Act 1948 by Y.A.B Prime Minister on 11/7/2012
Hindraf de facto leader Uthayakumar’s LTTE allegation civil suit : CJ & 4 UMNO Federal Court Judges dismiss 2 suits against govt of 1 Malay-sia in 1 day.
Media Event : 6/9/2012 : Interim Stay of Proceedings of Uthaya’s Sedition Charges @ Sessions Court: Hearing @ Federal Court on 6/9/2012 @ 9.00a.m.
Uthaya’s Sedition charge on “ethnic cleansing” letter to ex U.K PM. Sessions Court rejects stay of proceedings pending Federal Court appeal.